As professional anglers, having the right equipment can make all the difference in your fishing experience. In 2022, two of the most anticipated spinning reels were released by industry giants: Shimano's 22 Stella and Daiwa's 22 Exist. Both reels are top-tier in their class, designed with advanced technologies and aimed at providing the ultimate fishing performance. In this detailed comparison, we will analyze their features, performance, and overall value to help you decide which reel is the best fit for your needs.
Overview of Shimano 22 Stella
The Shimano 22 Stella continues the legacy of its predecessors, combining state-of-the-art technology with exceptional craftsmanship. Known for its smooth operation, durability, and innovative features, the 22 Stella is designed to meet the demands of the most discerning anglers.
Overview of Daiwa 22 Exist
The Daiwa 22 Exist is a formidable competitor, offering a blend of lightweight design and advanced engineering. Daiwa has focused on creating a reel that provides effortless performance with superior strength and resilience, making it a favorite among professional anglers.
Key Features Comparison
Gear Technology
Shimano 22 Stella:
- MicroModule II Gear System: The 22 Stella features Shimano's MicroModule II gear system, which ensures an incredibly smooth and silent operation. This technology uses smaller and more densely packed teeth on the gears, resulting in a smoother engagement and less gear noise.
- SilentDrive Technology: Further enhances the smoothness by minimizing internal friction and vibration.
Daiwa 22 Exist:
- Tough Digigear: Daiwa's Tough Digigear is designed for maximum durability and smoothness. This gear system uses precision-machined gears that offer a seamless and powerful performance.
- Monocoque Body (MQ): The monocoque body design of the Exist enhances rigidity and durability, providing a solid feel and improved power transmission.
Drag System
Shimano 22 Stella:
- Cross Carbon Drag: Provides a wide range of drag settings with exceptional smoothness and consistency. This system allows for precise adjustments, making it ideal for targeting various species.
Daiwa 22 Exist:
- ATD (Automatic Drag): Daiwa’s ATD system offers smooth and consistent drag pressure, adapting to the changing conditions during a fight. This technology helps maintain control over the fish, reducing the chances of line breakage.
Weight and Design
Shimano 22 Stella:
- The 22 Stella is slightly heavier than the Exist, but this added weight translates to increased durability and a robust feel. Shimano has carefully balanced the reel to minimize fatigue during long fishing sessions.
- Ergonomic Design: Features like the G Free Body and well-placed handles ensure a comfortable grip and optimal balance.
Daiwa 22 Exist:
- The 22 Exist is renowned for its lightweight design, making it one of the lightest reels in its class. This reduction in weight does not compromise its strength or performance.
- Air Rotor and Air Bail: These design elements further reduce weight while maintaining rigidity and strength.
Retrieve and Smoothness
Shimano 22 Stella:
- Smoothness: The MicroModule II gear system and SilentDrive technology make the 22 Stella one of the smoothest reels on the market. Every handle turn is effortless, providing a seamless retrieve experience.
- Feedback from Anglers: Many professional anglers have praised the 22 Stella for its incredibly smooth retrieve, even under heavy loads.
Daiwa 22 Exist:
- Silky Smooth Operation: The Tough Digigear and MAGSEALED technology contribute to the reel's smooth operation. The retrieve is consistently smooth, providing excellent feedback and control.
- Angler Insights: Users of the 22 Exist often highlight the silky smooth retrieve and the reel’s ability to maintain performance in various conditions.
Durability and Build Quality
Shimano 22 Stella:
- Built with durability in mind, the 22 Stella features a robust HAGANE Body and Gear. These components provide exceptional strength and longevity, making the reel suitable for the toughest fishing conditions.
- X-Protect: This technology enhances the reel's water resistance, protecting it from saltwater corrosion and debris.
Daiwa 22 Exist:
- The monocoque body of the Exist offers superior strength and rigidity. This design not only enhances the reel's durability but also improves power transmission.
- Long-Lasting Performance: The combination of MAGSEALED technology and high-quality materials ensures that the 22 Exist maintains its performance over time.
Casting Performance
Shimano 22 Stella:
- Long Stroke Spool: Improves casting distance and accuracy. This feature allows anglers to reach distant targets with ease and precision.
- Angler Feedback: Many professional anglers have noted the exceptional casting performance of the 22 Stella, making it ideal for both freshwater and saltwater fishing.
Daiwa 22 Exist:
- ABS (Anti Backlash System) Spool: Designed to reduce friction and improve casting distance. This system allows for smooth line flow, enhancing casting performance.
- User Experience: The 22 Exist is praised for its excellent casting capabilities, providing consistent and accurate casts.
Price and Value
Shimano 22 Stella:
- The 22 Stella is positioned at the higher end of the market, reflecting its premium features and build quality. While it is a significant investment, the performance and durability justify the cost for many professional anglers.
Daiwa 22 Exist:
- Similarly, the 22 Exist is priced at the premium end, offering advanced features and exceptional performance. Its lightweight design and innovative technologies provide excellent value for those looking to invest in a high-quality reel.
Final Verdict
Shimano 22 Stella:
-
Pros:
- Exceptional smoothness and quiet operation
- Robust and durable construction
- Superior drag performance
- Excellent casting distance and accuracy
-
Cons:
- Slightly heavier than the 22 Exist
- Higher price point
Daiwa 22 Exist:
-
Pros:
- Extremely lightweight and comfortable to use
- Silky smooth retrieve and operation
- Innovative design with excellent durability
- Superior water resistance
-
Cons:
- Higher price point
- Some anglers may prefer the slightly heavier feel of the 22 Stella for certain applications
Conclusion
Choosing between the Shimano 22 Stella and the Daiwa 22 Exist ultimately comes down to personal preference and specific fishing needs. Both reels offer exceptional performance, durability, and advanced features that cater to professional anglers.
- For those who prioritize smoothness and robust construction, the Shimano 22 Stella stands out with its MicroModule II gear system and HAGANE Body.
- For anglers who prefer a lightweight design with rapid retrieval, the Daiwa 22 Exist is an excellent choice, thanks to its Tough Digigear and monocoque body.
Both reels represent the pinnacle of fishing reel engineering and will undoubtedly enhance your fishing experience, whether you choose the 22 Stella or the 22 Exist.
